20210427 Update: Exploding Choke forces Conversion to L Match
Little is known about the risks of shunt feeding a telescoping tower for 160 but we have some anecdotal data indicating that care is needed. In my case, all was fine until RF decided it had to find a better way to the 40 meter yagi boom and or elements at the top of the stack. This is just a guess, but perhaps the driven element of the yagi "wanted" to be integral part of the system? A problem then arises when large currents reach the choke, which is designed to block such current flow. You can see below what 1500 watts of shunt fed power on 160 meters did to the choke! Check out VE6WZ's you tube and blog posts and you'll find a similar story.
click to enlarge
My options at this point were to install a relay to ground the driven element during 160 operation or to replace the choke with a proper high power balun and hope that it wouldn't arc. I decided to go for a new balun and chose the DxEngineering MC20 with the mounting hardware that's offered for it. Unfortunately, after installation the electrical length of the tower got shorter and I could no longer match it! We tried to find out why and even ran a wire all the way up connecting all the tower sections electrically, bypassed the balun, etc., but we were never able to determine the exact mechanism for the shortening after the new balun was installed. Now, my shunt fed tower was electrically short on 160! The Omega match will only match an antenna that is electrically long. (I have read posts on-line by hams wondering why they can't match a short tower on 160 with an omega match. If you're thinking of doing this, it won't work.) The solution was to convert to the classic L match. This resulted in a perfect match. Six months of subsequent rigorous high power testing during contests has not shown any failure or deterioration of the system.
The L match mounted on the wall of the barn.
The 2kw inductor is tapped at 7 uH and the capacitor is a 90-150 pF variable